Appeals Court Rejects Christian Therapist’s Lawsuit Against Washington State Over ‘Conversion Therapy’ Ban

Olu Ojo
Advertiser Disclosure

Hey there! We just wanted to let you know that some of the links on this site are affiliate links. That means we may get a commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy. Don't worry, though - we only recommend products that we personally use and love, and we promise to drink all the coffee from the money we make from affiliate sales. Thanks for your support, and we hope you find our content helpful! Read our disclosure.

In a pivotal move, an appeals court has firmly dismissed the appeal for a rehearing in the lawsuit brought forward by Christian therapist Brian Tingley against Washington state. Tingley’s challenge centered around the state’s prohibition of therapy for minors grappling with undesired same-sex attraction.

A Disputed Decision

Court of Appeal
Image credit: Court of Appeal

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit made the decisive vote on Monday, denying a full court rehearing for Tingley’s lawsuit. The therapist’s suit contested the Washington state law, sparking a heated debate on the grounds of First Amendment rights and the scope of speech protection.

Circuit Judge Diarmuid F. O’Scannlain, while respecting the order to deny the en banc rehearing, expressed his view that the earlier panel opinion was “erroneous.” O’Scannlain emphasized, “In sum, under binding Supreme Court precedents, conversion therapy consisting entirely of speech cannot be prohibited without some degree of First Amendment scrutiny.”

Divided Opinions

Legal Battle
Image credit: Depositphotos

A dissenting voice in this case, Circuit Judge Patrick J. Bumatay, argued that the full court should have given due consideration to Tingley’s First Amendment arguments. Bumatay noted, “Because the speech underpinning conversion therapy is overwhelmingly—if not exclusively—religious, we should have granted Tingley’s petition for en banc review.”

Despite the dissenting opinions, the court’s decision remained steadfast, marking a significant win for proponents of the conversion therapy ban.

Advocates Celebrate

Image credit: Canva

LGBTQ activist groups, including the National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR), who intervened in support of Washington state’s ban, hailed the decision. NCLR Legal Director Shannon Minter expressed, “These are common-sense protections that unfortunately are necessary to prevent unethical therapists from defrauding parents and causing severe harm to LGBTQ youth.”

Legislative Backdrop

15 Things That Appear Legal But are Perfectly Illegal in the U.S

In 2018, Washington state Governor Jay Inslee enacted Senate Bill 5722, effectively banning licensed therapists from conducting sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE) therapy on minors. Commonly known as conversion therapy or “reparative therapy,” SOCE therapy aims to modify or eliminate same-sex sexual attraction.

Tingley, unsatisfied with the exemption provided for religious organizations, filed the lawsuit in 2021. He asserted that the law inadequately safeguarded freedom of religion and speech.

Unanimous Ruling Against Tingley

Image credit: Canva

Last September, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit unanimously ruled against Tingley. Circuit Judge Ronald M. Gould, authoring the court opinion, posited that the state retained the authority to regulate medical practices. He stated, “States do not lose the power to regulate the safety of medical treatments… merely because those treatments are implemented through speech rather than through scalpel.”

Broader Implications

Ethics and Religion
Image credits: Canva

This development underscores the ongoing tension between religious freedom, ethical standards in therapy, and LGBTQ rights. The court’s decision reaffirms the state’s ability to enforce ethical standards and prohibit practices deemed harmful, particularly for minors.

20 American History “Facts” That We’ve Been Fooled Into Believing! Turns Out, They’re Actually Not True

20 American History “Facts” That We’ve Been Fooled Into Believing! Turns Out, They’re Actually Not True
Photo: © pixelshot via

You might think you’ve got your history down pat, but you’re about to have your world rocked — or at least your understanding of the past. Are you ready for a rollercoaster ride through the labyrinth of misconceptions, misunderstandings, and downright doozies that we’ve all been fooled into accepting as true? Hold onto your tricorn hats and let the unraveling of American history myths begin!

20 American History “Facts” That We’ve Been Fooled Into Believing! Turns Out, They’re Actually Not True

12 Nations That Give America the Cold Shoulder

Duncan1890 via

Yes, not all countries roll out the red carpet for the USA. So, grab your (virtual) passports and your sense of adventure; this promises to be a ride as bumpy as it is enlightening. Here’s a look at international relations and exploration of these frosty receptions. Have you got your parka on? Good. Let’s go!

12 Nations That Give America the Cold Shoulder

The 9 Best Travel Backpacks For Women in 2024

The 9 Best Travel Backpacks For Women in 2023
Photo: ©

To assist you in making an informed purchasing decision, we’ve compiled all the necessary information and curated a list of the top nine travel backpacks for women. Rest assured, we’ve got you covered every step of the way on your exciting journey.

The 9 Best Travel Backpacks For Women in 2024

15 Things That Americans Absolutely Won’t Put Up With, No Way!

15 Things That Americans Absolutely Won’t Put Up With, No Way!
Pixelshot via

Welcome, folks, to the unofficial guide of “Don’t You Dare” – America edition. We’ve all got our peculiarities, our quirks, and our non-negotiables. But some things simply cross the line if you’re from the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave.
This isn’t just about preferences, oh no! We’re talking about those “drop the mic” moments that make every American say, “No way, not on my watch!” This is a tour of 15 things Americans absolutely won’t put up with. Let’s roll!

15 Things That Americans Absolutely Won’t Put Up With, No Way!

20 Things Americans Nail Like a Boss (While Others Struggle To Keep Up)

20 Things Americans Nail Like a Boss (While Others Struggle To Keep Up)
Jacob Lund via

Picture this: You’re in a bustling city, surrounded by skyscrapers that touch the clouds, with a steaming cup of Joe in one hand and the other catching a ball thrown halfway across the field without missing a beat. You’re probably in America. Why? Because Americans do certain things so well, it seems like second nature.


  • Olu Ojo

    My name is Olu. I am a passionate entrepreneur who loves to write about Pets, Home Improvement Hacks & Products, Fitness, and Travel Lifestyle. I have two bachelor's degrees in Veterinary Medicine and Applied Accounting with a CPA designation. I currently shuffle time between completing a Master of Business Administration Degree Education, Professional Practice, and Content writing. I have freelanced lifestyle content and posts for many top authority websites like MSN, and Wealth of Geeks.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Frenz Lifestyle & Wellness Blog

For Lifestyle trends, tips, and best product reviews

Join Our Subscriber List Today!

This will close in 0 seconds